Full-face or modular helmet?
March/April 2009
By Motorcycle Classics staff
 |
Z1R Eclipse
|
Helmets 1-4 are standard full-face helmets and 5-7 are modular full-face helmets. What’s the difference? Standard full-face helmets have a fixed chin bar, while modular helmets have a hinged chin bar that can be rotated up (like the Z1R Eclipse at right), handy when you’re filling your bike with gas or paying at the toll booth. Though we often see people riding around wearing modular full-face helmets with the chinbar in the “up” position, most of these helmets say right on the helmet that they should be closed when moving.
RELATED CONTENT
Motorcycle Classics guide to helmets you'll want to wear....
A review of seven touring helmets....
A sticker can't fix a non-DOT approved helmet....
A closer look at 10 riding jackets to keep you safe and cool in the summer....
While we’ve come to regard modular full-face helmets as very useful, some people like them and some don’t. It’s just a matter of preference.
In most instances, Editor Hall prefers a standard full-face helmet as opposed to a modular full-face helmet, as they’re often a little quieter and a little lighter.
Editor Backus and Publisher Bryan Welch both prefer flip-up helmets because they’re convenient. The remaining question is the safety of modular helmets. Though all the helmets here are at least DOT approved, none of the modular helmets pass stricter helmet testing, such as the Snell or ECE 22-05 standards. Some people believe in these tests, and some don’t. Again, it’s a personal decision.
So which kind of helmet is right for you? Our best advice is to try on a variety of helmets yourself. Both standard and modular full-face helmets have their advantages, but if you haven’t bought a new helmet in a while, you may be impressed with the level of quality and list of features available in a variety of price ranges.