Which Bonnie is the Best?

We take a look at three eras of the famed Triumph to find out which Bonnie was the best.

By Motorcycle Classics Staff
Updated on June 23, 2021
article image
A 1968 U.K. model Bonnie.

1963-1970 Triumph 650 Bonneville T120R

  • Claimed power: 52hp @ 6,500rpm
  • Top speed: 109mph/112mph (period tests)
  • Engine: 649cc (71 x 82mm) 2-valve air-cooled OHV parallel twin, 4-speed, chain final drive
    Weight: 363lb (dry), 390lb (curb)
  • Fuel capacity/MPG: 3.5 gals/N/A
  • Price then/now: $1,375 (1970)/$6,000-$20,000

Conventional wisdom says the 1968-1970 Triumph 650 Bonnevilles were the best, the product of a decade of continuous development. The crack-prone pre-unit duplex frame was history, and the 1963-on unit-construction engine was more compact and needed less maintenance. Balance factor and flywheel changes moderated vibration, camshafts were nitrided to reduce wear, and the 1968-on twin leading shoe brake was a potent stopper. The engine was mostly oil-tight, thanks to improved breathing and revised pushrod tube seals. Already becoming a classic, the 1970 Bonneville wasn’t broke and didn’t need fixin’.

But they fixed it anyway. BSA Group’s in-house think tank, a safe distance from Triumph’s Meriden factory, dreamed up a new welded chassis that carried oil in its frame tubes, dispensing with the oil tank. Though built around BSA’s unit construction 650, it was also supposed to fit the Triumph 650.

At Meriden, everything that could go wrong, did. The new frame would not accept the Bonneville engine with the rocker boxes in situ, slowing production, while the seat height leapt to an ankle-stretching 34 inches. Frothing inside the frame “tank” meant reducing oil capacity, with the potential for overheating. Frames fractured around the center stand mounts, creating oil leaks. Because of these and other issues (a new computerized ordering system for one) BSA/Triumph missed the lucrative Spring sales season in 1971 — one of the reasons they ran out of cash in 1972. Fairly or not, the unloved oil-in-frame Bonnie got the blame.

But was this dissing deserved? Aside from its faults (and its eccentric styling) the OIF 650 of 1971-1972 brought in much-needed upgrades, like the welded frame, 5-speed transmission and turn signals. Most of its flaws were corrected during 1972, and paved the way for the disc-braked, 750cc Bonneville T140V of 1973.

Online Store Logo
Need Help? Call 1-800-880-7567